Foreign policy is a 41page, amateurish and biased critique of israel, american jews, and american policy. How israel s lobby moves america, while providing insight into likely israel lobby demands on the next administration. Foreign policy, a book by john mearsheimer and stephen walt. I would like, first, to defend the book against four of the major criticisms, and then raise four sets of critical questions of my own. It and the longer paper that is based on has generated some controversy. The power of americas jewish lobby is said to be legendary. The controversial tome challenging the might of the proisrael lobby is nonetheless accused of shoddy scholarship much as when the authors shorter paper on the subject in 2006 unexpectedly burst the bubble of a lobby. Foreign policy mahmood ahmad the dialogue 2 volume iii, number 1 israel is considered to be americas best friend by president george w. Bbc news americas us storm over book on israel lobby. Though often justified as reflecting shared strategic interests or compelling moral imperatives, the u. If we think of a spectrum with influence at one end shading into control at the other, in the decade since the israel lobby was published israel has moved closer to the control end of the spectrum. This paper describes the various activities that pro israel groups have undertaken in order to shift u. Kennedy school of government, was one of the most controversial articles in recent memory. Many are active on capitol hill, drafting legislation to economically and militarily target israel s regional rivals and deliver the largest slice of the us foreign aid budget to israel.
Foreign policy would not be taken seriously if not for. Walt farrar, strauss and giroux, 2007, paperback p83 today, israel is the strongest military power in the middle east. Foreign policy is not even in bookstores, but already anxieties have surfaced about the backlash it is stirring, with. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. For example, we learn from the israeli newspaper haaretz that a bill in the us house of representatives would require u. It consists of a multitude of institutions and individuals that work to influence congress, the president, academia, the media, religious institutions, and american public opinion on behalf of israel. Mearsheimer of the university of chicagos department of political science and stephen m. Apr 10, 2015 hundreds of organizations and thousands of individuals lobby the us government at every level to support israel unconditionally. Us storm over book on israel lobby by henri astier bbc news the bush administration like its predecessors has stood by israel. Mar 01, 2008 the economist, too, in its customary succinct and understated fashion, determined on september 29, 2007 that the books main thesis that the israel lobby was critical in persuading george. Among these are jewish groups that have come under renewed criticism for being part of an allpowerful israel lobby, most notably in a book published this week by profs.
The central thesis of the book is that the israel lobby, a loosely connected and farreaching group of highmovers and grassroot activists devoted to supporting israel. Mar 27, 2006 the authors have been attacked for engaging in a monocausal argument i. Kennedy school of government at harvard, entitled the israel lobby and u. Cnns wolf blitzer, while not an israeli citizen, was based in israel for many years, wrote a book whitewashing israeli spying on the us, and used to work for the israel lobby in the us. Mailing address counterpunch po box 228 petrolia, ca 95558 telephone 1707 6293683. If an internal link led you here, you may wish to change the link to point directly to the. Walt of harvard universitys kennedy school of government contend that the centerpiece of u.
Listen to this audiobook excerpt from the israel lobby and u. Smith discusses key points developed in his new book, big israel. This disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title israel lobby. Mar 15, 2006 though often justified as reflecting shared strategic interests or compelling moral imperatives, the u. In 1931 the gershwin brothers wrote of thee i sing, the first musical to win a pulitzer. America takes side of israel jeff jacoby, boston globe, march 26, 2006. An unfair attack david gergen kennedy school faculty member, us. In the past, the israel lobby had one feature which distinguished it from, say, the irish lobby. Foreign policy is not even in bookstores, but already anxieties have surfaced about the backlash it is stirring, with several institutions backing away from holding. Instantly, the authors and the book were denounced as anti.
Oct 02, 2007 the israel lobby and us foreign policy by john j. Mearsheimer and stephen walts article, titled the israel lobby and u. The correct term, as hagel quickly acknowledged last week, is israel lobby. The united states, israel, and the lobby part 2 excerpted from the book the israel lobby and u. Jan 01, 2006 the israel lobby asserts what almost 40% per the authors of americans recognize that israel is one of the main causes of antiamericanism, that the u. The israel lobby john mearsheimer and stephen walt for the past several decades, and especially since the sixday war in 1967, the centrepiece of us middle eastern policy has been its relationship with israel. The israel lobby was a player in the discussion on going to war, but there is little evidence to regard its role as decisive. Commentators the world over refer to it, as though it were a wellestablished fact that us jews wield far more influence than their numbers 2% of the. Middle east policy is its intimate relationship with israel.
Tikkuns editor michael lerner has a son who served in the israeli military. The israel lobby s impact on americavideo guest lecturer grant f. Harvard posts rebuttal to paper charles radin, boston globe, april 6, 2006 israel lobby critique roils academe charles radin, boston globe, march 29, 2006. The authors argue that although often justified as reflecting shared strategic interests or compelling moral. Walt, distinguished scholars at two of americas top universities. Ten years ago, john mearsheimer and i published a controversial article and subsequent book examining the impact of the israel lobby that is, a loose coalition of proisrael individuals.
Dec 23, 2007 it has been 21 months since john mearsheimer and steve walt published their article the israel lobby and u. How not to think about the israel lobby foreign policy. This book is a mustread for anybody who wanting to know the objective truth about how israel manipulates the us government, msm and college campuses. This paper goes on to describe the various activities that proisrael groups have undertaken in order to shift u.
Books critical of the lobby have been published before, as preston and schoenbaum note. The united states, israel, and the lobby part 2 excerpted. The lobby and israel policy as i acknowledged in my original article, the israel lobby is far more influential regarding u. Mearsheimer of the university of chicago and stephen m. This paper describes the various activities that proisrael groups have undertaken in order to shift u. The authors argue that although often justified as reflecting shared strategic interests or compelling moral imperatives, the u. Many are active on capitol hill, drafting legislation to economically and militarily target israels regional rivals and deliver the largest slice of the us foreign aid budget to israel. A nation like ours jeff jacoby, boston globe, march 29, 2006. May 01, 2006 mailing address counterpunch po box 228 petrolia, ca 95558 telephone 1707 6293683. So, just how powerful is the israel lobby in the us. The israel lobby john mearsheimer, stephen walt 1 for the past several decades, and especially since the sixday war in 1967, the centrepiece of us middle eastern policy has been its relationship with israel. The economist, too, in its customary succinct and understated fashion, determined on september 29, 2007 that the books main thesis that the israel lobby was critical in persuading george. The israel lobbys impact on americavideo guest lecturer grant f.
Is it that the book advances an onesidedly antiisrael version of contemporary mideast history or arabisraeli relations, as preston and schoenbaum argue. Walt thou the cover of this copy was in rough shape and by the some of stuff in this book is dated by now the book published in 2007 and article the book is based on came out 2006 is very educational and informative and also is fairly easy to read and. They deal with a subject which is absolutely taboo in the united states, a subject nobody in his right mind would even mention. Foreign policy is a book by john mearsheimer, professor of political science at the university of chicago, and stephen walt, professor of international relations at the kennedy school of government at harvard university, published in late august 2007. The israel lobby and us foreign policy by professors john j. Apr 12, 2012 listen to this audiobook excerpt from the israel lobby and u. Moreover, most americans would support israels right to exist and to defend itself against threats even if the israel lobby did not exist.
Sep 06, 2007 the israel lobby and us foreign policy by professors john j. Sep 09, 2007 among these are jewish groups that have come under renewed criticism for being part of an allpowerful israel lobby, most notably in a book published this week by profs. Although this book focuses primarily on the lobbys influence on u. Reading the israel lobby and us foreign policy is a rather dispiriting experience when one grasps how highly lauded it is by so many people. Jul 27, 2017 the authors conclude that the use of us foreign policy in israels interests is damaging to both americas national interests and to israels longterm security. The response to the israel lobby the american conservative. Foreign policy in mearsheimer and walts cartography, the israel lobby is not limited to aipac, the american israel public affairs committee. Israeli relations as well the authors are particularly inaccurate in their assessment regarding the influence of the. Its conventional forces are far superior to those of its neighbors, and it. May 04, 2018 the israel lobby is one of the most powerful and pervasive special interest groups in the u. This book is a mustread for anybody who wanting to know the.
Many were pleased that two distinguished experts had breached a taboo issue. The israel lobby is one of the most powerful and pervasive special interest groups in the u. The controversial tome challenging the might of the pro israel lobby is nonetheless accused of shoddy scholarship much as when the authors shorter paper on the subject in 2006 unexpectedly burst the bubble of a lobby unaccustomed to challenge. Many critics tried to smear us by either saying or hinting that we are antisemitic. Other specialinterest groups have managed to skew foreign policy, but no lobby has managed to divert it as far from what the national interest would suggest, while simultaneously convincing americans that us interests and those of the other country in this case. At some events to promote the book, sponsors have turned down or. How israels lobby moves america, while providing insight into likely israel lobby demands on the next administration. The authors have been attacked for engaging in a monocausal argument i. Americas generosity toward israel is beyond compare in modern history.
1243 79 1243 871 70 596 137 491 159 408 1205 1143 391 755 1328 1429 1497 12 1460 976 266 664 447 855 1311 179 1531 960 855 752 1331 1423 254 158 666